Thursday, July 18, 2013

Global News this evening on the PFRA pastures


screen capture from Global web site
"Saskatchewan’ community pastures are public lands, which ranchers can pay a fee to access. For more than 70 years, community ranching pastures have brought communities together. When the federal government decided in the last budget to turn over those pastures to the province to be sold, those communities have come together again – so they won’t lose them.

For many producers, the community pastures mean one thing: community."


Those lines are from Global TV News web site this evening. Global reporter Raquel Fletcher does a good job with the story which you can view here.  Raquel came out to the media conference we held with Margaret Atwood and the others on the BirdLife International tour and seemed to be listening intently, picking up the issues at hand quickly.


It would be great to see her interview FSIN on the topic and see what they have to say.

image courtesy of Hamilton Greenwood


Thursday, July 11, 2013

Pasture Patrons and First Nations speak out this week

CPPAS chair Ian McCreary of Bladworth talking pastures issues with Graeme Gibson (image courtesy of Branimir Gjetvaj)
Yesterday, the Community Pastures Patrons Association of Saskatchewan called for a one year delay to give them and the two levels of government enough time to work out the details of any transition. (Here is an article based on their media release, published in today's Leader-Post.)

Rushing things appears to be a way to intimidate the patron groups into accepting terms in a "take it or leave it" proposition. Meanwhile, there are not so subtle messages coming from various quarters suggesting that if the patrons do not take what is offered now, there are third parties waiting in the wings for their chance to snap up the leases. Before that happens, though, there is another interested party with a very strong legal position. Today, they spoke up loud and clear.

FSIN Chief Perry Bellegarde

Federation of Saskatchewan First Nations head, Perry Bellegarde published an op-ed in the Saskatoon Star-Phoenix that everyone who is interested in what happens to the PFRA pastures needs to read.
“I cannot stress enough the importance of our groups working together and forming partnerships to ensure the conservation and protection of our ecological values and the diversity of Saskatchewan’s rich grasslands, as well as to ensure that the Crown meets its lawful obligation to satisfy outstanding Treaty Land Entitlements.” – Perry Bellegarde, FSIN chief
Too often forgotten in the discussion of what will happen to the pastures, the First Nations voice has the potential to resolve the issues that seem to be separating private and public interests in these critically important native grasslands.

The beautiful Auvergne Wise Creek PFRA Pasture--as of today, still under federal management



Tuesday, July 9, 2013

What do we mean by “professional managers”?


Clint Christianson showing us Val Marie PFRA pasture  (image courtesy of Colin Hubick, Red Hat Studios)



[First, look at this video based on footage Colin Hubick shot on the BirdLife tour. He is hoping to get some funding to make a full documentary on the PFRA story.]

One of PPPI’s six principles on how the PFRA pastures should be transitioned says that any new system should “utilize professional pasture managers”. When we drafted those principles way back in March, I remember agonizing over that word, “professional.”


I was worried that people might think we believe hired pasture managers always do a better job than the guys who manage their own native range that they lease or own privately. Or that there are no patrons who have the skills and capacity to manage native grass pastures themselves. Of course that is not true so we looked in vain for other ways of saying what we meant but it was hard to do it without a lot of explaining. Maybe now is a good time to try.



First, though, it is important to say that anyone who is making money managing their land is by definition a professional. And most of the cattle producers who graze Crown lease land are very skilled professionals. They learned from their forbears that overstocking will hurt them in the long run, and that it is not wise to use too much of the resource. Many of them take advantage of training and advice offered by government extension programs, but they start from a base of traditional knowledge that must be recognized and valued.

So, what’s the problem? What would happen to the PFRA pastures if each one was sold to a single rancher who comes from that tradition of stewardship? As long as the land was managed by that single rancher, I believe that the ecological condition and biodiversity of the pastures would become more or less be much like the rest of our Crown lease land—which means it would be pretty good on average—some terrific, others less so.
Ian McCreary, Chair of Community Pastures Patron Association of Saskatchewan (image courtesy of Colin Hubick, Red Hat Studios)

By and large the Crown lease land in Saskatchewan is well managed and still good habitat for birds and other native species that are in trouble. But, here’s the rub. If we sell these great pieces of grassland to private ranchers, not only do we put hundreds of small to mid-sized cattlemen out of business, there is nothing to guarantee that sound management over the long term. The first buyer’s good stewardship will only last as long as they own the land and keep it in one piece. Sooner or later they will sell or die and the second buyer may not be from the longstanding Saskatchewan tradition of good stewardship. They could claim undue hardship and get a court to remove the conservation easement that protects the land from cultivation. Or simply subdivide the land and sell it in parcels, or graze it much more heavily. Once it is no longer owned by the Crown, anything is possible.


However, the Province is telling us that, instead of selling the land, they plan to lease out most of the PFRA pastures to groups of the existing pasture patrons—some of which are ten, twenty, or thirty strong. Now, instead of a single cattle producer/steward making the management decisions in his own long term best interest, which often coincides with conservation interests, you have ten or twenty cattlemen with varying ideas of how the land should be stocked and managed.


Without an independent “professional” (for lack of a better term) management system that is the final word on how many cattle go where and when and how much grass to keep back, there is bound to be at best a few disagreements and a low common denominator of management that over time will push the land harder than it has been under the PFRA system. At worst, you may well end up with the scenario described in Garret Hardin’s Tragedy of the Commons argument: i.e. “the depletion of a shared resource by individuals, acting independently and rationally according to each one's self-interest, despite their understanding that depleting the common resource is contrary to the group's long-term best interests.” (Wikipedia)


How would that tragedy look on a former PFRA pasture? Well, it would look like many (some would say most but not all) of the “co-op” pastures in the province, where the land is divided up into smaller fields and each member gets his own piece to graze more or less as he sees fit. No unitary management system, no co-mingled herds managed in a system that is based on a coherent plan. Short term interests win out and over time you get degraded pastures and reduced biodiversity and habitat for endangered species.



PFRA patrons that I speak to are concerned that, if the lease rates, taxes and other costs set by the Province are as high as they are being asked for, there will not be enough money left on the table for them to afford hiring an independent manager who sticks to a plan in good times and in bad. Rest-rotation systems would be replaced by season-long grazing in fields that are too small. And if market or weather conditions go the wrong way, there will be pressure to use the grass more heavily than they would like to.
Clint Christianson, Val Marie rancher and long time patron of Val Marie and Lone Tree PFRA pastures (image courtesy of Colin Hubick, Red Hat Studios)


The overall productivity of the land will drop over time, hurting the cattle producers. That in turn hurts the local community, and degrades the public asset we invested in for more than 75 years restoring the ecology and biodiversity of these conservation lands.


Finally, there is another side to what we mean by “professional” management. And that is a management system that is accountable to the public and its interest in the ecological wellbeing of the land. Such a system would have to balance conservation values with economic/grazing values and settles on a lower stocking rate to strike that balance—just as the PFRA always did. Range managers will tell you that Crown lease land is generally stocked at a higher rate than the PFRA pastures have been. That is part of the reason why, on average, the PFRA pastures have for example been superior bird habitat, especially for species that like longer grass and a lot of carry over in their habitat.


No matter how good a private steward might be with his land, if he is paying for a higher stocking rate set by the Province he will be inclined to stock at that rate. And the Province, under the NDP and the Sask Party, has been all too willing to push the land to pull in maximum revenue for the treasury. In a better world, all of our publicly owned native grasslands—Crown lease and community pastures—would give the cattlemen a lower lease rate and keep the stocking rates low enough to ensure that our pastures are good for both cattle producers and a wide range of species at risk.

That dual management for both cattle and biodiversity and ecological health is what we need to find a way to retain from the PFRA model—both by recognizing, and fostering the knowledge of our cattlemen, and by connecting it with a management system that will ensure that they are not left holding the bag for species at risk and all the other public benefits that you and I receive from them.


So many of our ranchers are terrific stewards—anyone who travels in the southwest of the province can see that--but we have an opportunity here with the transition of the PFRA lands to do something that will ensure that that ethic will be a part of the way our publicly owned grasslands are managed and protected for everyone’s benefit. We need to find ways to protect that ethic, to recognize it, foster it and divide the costs of being a good manager among all Canadians. How we work that out would require a discussion that brings together agriculture and conservation, economy and ecology—but the discussion will have to begin with the people who live and work on the land.

Photographer Branimir Gjetvaj at work on Val Marie Pasture (image courtesy of Colin Hubick, Red Hat Studios)

Saturday, June 29, 2013

A week of listening to birds and cattlemen


pasture patron Brent Cammer showing a map of the Swift Current-Webb PFRA pasture to Margaret Atwood on Thursday (image from Craig Baird of the Gull Lake Advance)
I am still processing the time we spent this week touring PFRA pastures and other publicly owned grasslands with Margaret Atwood, author and naturalist Graeme Gibson, Ian Davidson (Nature Canada's Executive Director) and Alberto Yanosky (Executive Director of Paraguay's BirdLife affiliate, Guyra Paraguay).

So what was this tour about? It was a week of listening to birds and cattlemen, of travelling through stunning prairie landscapes, and learning about how cattle are part of the ecological wellbeing of our publicly owned grasslands, including Grasslands National Park and the federal PFRA pasture system that I write about here so often in this space.

But it was also a week of stories. We had some great story tellers and story listeners on the tour with us. I caught myself more than once looking over at Margaret and Graeme to see how they were responding to the things we heard from pasture patrons and pasture managers.

Whether it was Wes Olson talking about bison in the National Park, or a rancher talking about driving cattle to the PFRA pasture with his father when he was a boy, our four guests listened intently. I could see they were taking it all in with great empathy and awareness, incorporating it into their understanding of how habitat protection and bird conservation happens from the ground up, with local people who live on the landscape leading the way. One of the reasons Margaret and Graeme like BirdLife International is that its programs for protecting birds and their wild places start with at the grassroots, where people live and work with nature in their communities.

All week we heard stories about birds, cattle, ranchers, buffalo, about the struggle to hold onto community and to make a living in grassland grazing cattle. From Don Gillespie, one of the West Block’s living legends, we heard stories about how ranch families still get together in the local community to brand their cattle,moving from ranch to ranch through the spring and early summer.

listening to Don Gillespie as we view some of the new pastures recently added to Grasslands National Park (Don is in the middle in all denim. To the right of Don is GNP Superintendent, Katherine Patterson, wearing scarf.)



We watched burrowing owls perch on signs and rocks inside and outside the boundaries of the national park--at least three pairs.

We found out that Long-billed Curlews love to forage on prairie dog towns.

We learned that while Val Marie has no gas station any more, it does have some great spots for people to rest up and refuel—places like the Crossing, The Convent, and The Harvest Moon restaurant.
Pasture patron Clint Chritianson speaking to us on the Val Marie PFRA pastures (image courtesy of Branimir Gjetvaj)

We learned that big men in cowboy hats have soft hearts and a lot of love for the pastures they graze.One of my favourite moments was when Clint Christianson, a patron of Lone Tree and Val Marie PFRA pastures, leaned out of his truck and said with obvious pride, “it's native grass all the way from here to Val Marie!” We were about 50 kilometres from town at the time and we drove through the lush and bird-filled Val Marie pasture all the way.

And Don Gillespie, with the same look in his eye, pointing to the north and boasting that from the divide just beyond the horizon all the way south to Montana and east to Poverty Ridge, it’s native grass. These ranchers know that the grass in these big pastures is unique in Canada and worth every effort to keep it intact.

We learned too that while GNP has 10,000 tipi rings, it has fewer than 7500 visitors a year. Those who come though, almost always come back—for the silence, the darkness, the birds and flowers, and for the stories. 

We heard stories abt how cattle as well as bison are grazing in different parts of the Park—thanks to the hard work of the Park Superintendant, Katherine Patterson, who has expanded on the work of her predecessors and is creating a new era of good relations between the park and the surrounding ranch families.

Many of the most compelling stories came from Wes Olson, retired bison steward for Parks Canada who still lives in Val Marie. Wes is a living library of knowledge abt the bison and their role in prairie ecosystems—the niches they create, setting the table for so many other creatures, by making wallows, by grazing, shedding their fur, trampling the soil, leaving their patties, and then dying on the land.

But we also heard that because of budget cuts, Parks Canada no longer has anyone in the area to look after the bison and no way to retain and carry forward Wes’s wisdom and skill.

From several pasture patrons who keep animals on the PFRA pastures, we learned that most of them feel like the government of Saskatchewan is not really listening to them; that the terms they are being offered are not reasonable, that it will not leave enough money on the table to let them afford proper grazing management and the kind of lower stocking rates that would sustain the native grasslands properly.

Again and again we heard this story; again and again we heard that they feel rushed and need more time.

And that is why at the news conference yesterday Public Pastures-Public Interest called for a one year delay on the transfer of the first ten pastures.

"The government is not listening. . . ." Margaret in a media scrum at our news conference on Friday (image courtesy of Metro News)




Above all, Margaret Atwood, Graeme Gibson and the other guests showed us that listening to one another is important, and we still have a lot more listening to do before we get this right.

I could say more about what we learned on the tour, but no matter what happens from here on, I know that having Margaret, Graeme, Ian and Alberto on the tour and meeting the people we met, hearing their stories, will in the long run help us make those connections between ranchers and conservationists that are so critical as we look for ways to continue managing these last great grassland ecosystems for the good of our small to mid-sized cattle producers, for the good of our rural communities, and for all of the wider public goods they provide to the rest of us.


Margaret and Graeme sharing a moment at Swift Current-Webb pasture (image courtesy of Craig Baird of the Gull Lake Advance)


Monday, June 17, 2013

Margaret Atwood on the Saskatchewan Community Pastures



This morning on CBC Radio Saskatchewan, Sheila Coles talked with Margaret Atwood (listen here) about the PFRA pastures she will be coming to visit next week along with other BirdLife International representatives on a fact-finding tour. By the end of the ten minute interview she is talking about how we all need to find manageable environmental causes to which we can lend our energies and time. Otherwise, we can feel quite helpless in the face of government failure and the many complex and compounding ecological problems besetting the world.

There are still a few tickets left for the banquet where Margaret, her partner Graeme and the other BirdLife guests will be honoured. Details here on the Facebook page for the event.

This young Loggerhead Shrike is one of many species who depend on the well-managed grasslands of our publicly-owned community pastures. We hope to see some on the tour June 24-27.


Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Western Producer piece on protecting the value of the federal pastures

The closest thing I could find to grassland in Tuscany--that is Karen in the pink hat. Skylarks were singing overhead!
[Back from a three week vacation--hence the gap in posts here on Grass Notes. My wife Karen and I celebrated our 25th anniversary (four years late) by travelling to Italy, Corsica, France and the Netherlands with a couple we have known for all of those years.]

So why is it that many of the PFRA pasture patrons are uncertain about the lease and ownership deals being offered to them by the Province of Saskatchewan? A big part of it is economics but many producers, particularly from the Southwest where the culture of stewardship is strong, are expressing concern that if there is not any funding support for proper ecosystem based management, the leasing patron groups will likely end up having to default to poorer management systems instead of the planned rest-rotation cycles that have kept most of the federal community pastures in top condition for both cattle and biodiversity.

Some of these concerns are expressed in an article published this week in the Western Producer. Written by Public Pastures--Public Interest members Josef Schmutz and Katherine Arbuthnott, it looks at some of the wider economic issues that are being carefully ignored in many quarters. Katherine is a professor and assistant dean at the University of Regina’s Campion College, with research in conservation psychology. Joe is an adjunct professor in the University of Saskatchewan’s School of Environment and Sustain-ability, with research in grassland ecology.

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Atwood Dinner June 27--please help spread the word


Margaret Atwood
Graeme Gibson (image courtesy of Dennis Minty)


Friends,

You may have heard the exciting news that from June 24 to June 28, Margaret Atwood and Graeme Gibson, two of Canada’s most celebrated authors, will tour Saskatchewan’s southern grasslands in the company of other international conservation advocates. They will be hosted by Public Pastures - Public Interest and Nature Canada.

This is an educational tour. The group, all prominent figures in BirdLife International, a worldwide partnership of conservation organizations, is hoping to draw attention to the global significance of conservation programming and bird habitat at risk on federal PFRA community pastures now being transferred to Saskatchewan.

How you can help

I would like to ask that you help to promote the Prairie Passages fundraising dinner at the Radisson Plaza Hotel Saskatchewan in Regina on Thursday, June 27.

After dinner Atwood and Gibson will speak, reflecting on their visit to our grasslands and pastures, the birdlife and species at risk, and their own passion for conservation. There will be great images from the tour, music, and a chance to meet our international guests.

Here is how you can help:

  1. Circulate the handbill for the dinner (click here to download the pdf) to your contacts, organization members, and friends. Print it off and share it.
  2. Post the notice below in your newsletters and social media networks. Here is the link to the PPPI dinner announcement with details.
  3. Encourage your friends and colleagues to buy tickets or sponsor a corporate table.
  4. Call the Globe Theatre for a ticket for yourself and be a part of this event!
  5. Watch for more updates on the tour.
Our other tour guests are prominent in their own right. They are: Glenn Olson, National Audubon Society; Rob Clay, BirdLife International; Dr. Alberto Yanosky, from Paraguay, Southern Cone initiative and BirdLife International; and, Ian Davidson, Executive Director of Nature Canada.

Pictures suitable for the internet are shown at the top of this post. Please include the photo credit for Dennis Minty for Graeme Gibson’s photo.

*************************
EVENT NOTICE:

Prairie Passages Dinner: An Evening with Margaret Atwood and Graeme Gibson
Radisson Plaza Hotel Saskatchewan in Regina, Regency Ballroom
Thursday, June 27, Cocktails at 6:30 P.M. Dinner at 7:30 P.M.

Join two of Canada’s most celebrated authors, conservationists, and prominent members of BirdLife International as they reflect on their passion for birds, wildlife, grasslands, and their recent travels in Saskatchewan. This is an educational event. The dinner is the highlight of the Prairie Passages tour with Atwood, Gibson, and other international guests from the conservation community. The purpose is draw attention to the global significance of conservation programming and bird habitat at risk on federal PFRA community pastures now being transferred to Saskatchewan.

Your MC will be Candace Savage, one of Saskatchewan’s most respected writers. Her most recent book, A Geography of Blood: Unearthing Memory from a Prairie Landscape, won the $60,000 Hilary Weston Writers’ Trust Prize for Nonfiction and the 2013 Saskatchewan Book of the Year Award.

This event is hosted by Public Pastures-Public Interest and Nature Canada. Visit the dinner webpage:

Tickets: $100, available at the Globe Theatre Box Office:

Share this post

Get widget